What Happens at the NMC Case Examiner Stage? Warning, Undertakings or Hearing
At the NMC case examiner stage, two case examiners review the evidence from the investigation and decide whether there is a case to answer. If there is not, they can give advice, issue a warning or close the case. If there is, they can recommend undertakings or refer you to a Fitness to Practise Committee hearing. At CrownEthics, we wrote this guide for nurses, midwives and nursing associates whose case is at, or heading for, that stage.
Before case examiners decide
Speak to your union, professional body or representative. They know your case and can advise on what to include in your response.
Read the NMC’s concerns carefully. Note what you accept, what you dispute and what context is missing.
Keep to every deadline. If you need more time, ask through your representative before the date passes.
Show reflection and what you have changed. Specific, dated evidence carries more weight than general assurances.
Do not contact the person who raised the concern. It can be misread as trying to influence the process.
Who are the NMC case examiners?
There are two case examiners on each case. One is a nurse, midwife or nursing associate, and the other is not. They review the evidence gathered so far and decide whether there is a case to answer.
What you have already sent the NMC matters here. If you have not yet written about what happened, our guide to your first steps after an NMC investigation letter and our guide to writing a reflective statement for the NMC will help.
What is the “case to answer” test?
Case examiners ask two questions. First, is there a realistic possibility that the Fitness to Practise Committee would decide from the evidence that the incidents happened or the issues persist? Second, is there a realistic possibility that it would find your fitness to practise currently impaired?
When they look at impairment, they ask whether you are currently a risk to the health, safety or wellbeing of the public. If you are not, they then ask whether action is needed to maintain public confidence or professional standards. The NMC says cases without a patient safety risk only go forward where the concerns are fundamental to your ability to uphold the standards and values in the Code.
What outcomes can they reach?
1Close the case, with or without adviceNo case to answer+
2A warning12 months on the register+
3Recommended undertakingsAgreed with you+
4Referral to a hearingFitness to Practise Committee+
What do case examiners look at on insight and remediation?
The NMC says case examiners pay close attention to its guidance on insight and strengthened practice. In practice, that means:
- The quality of your reflection: whether it shows you understand what went wrong and why.
- The steps you have taken: training, supervision, changes to how you work.
- The likelihood of repetition: what evidence there is that it will not happen again.
The NMC’s own guidance says it should try to avoid sending cases to the Fitness to Practise Committee if the nurse, midwife or nursing associate accepts the concerns and they can be addressed. That does not mean a case will close, but it is why insight and evidence of change matter at this stage.
Two nurses respond to a similar concern about a medication record. The first writes that she was short-staffed, that it will not happen again, and attaches a general training certificate. The second explains what happened at each step, accepts where her checks fell short, describes the double-check routine she now follows, and attaches a certificate from a course on the topic with a dated reflection on what she changed. Neither outcome is guaranteed, but the second gives case examiners specific evidence of insight and strengthened practice to weigh.
What evidence helps most?
The strongest evidence is specific, relevant and dated. A course can be part of it when it matches the concern and is followed by honest reflection and a change in how you work.
Our NMC remediation courses include Insight, which teaches the four-part framework behind the insight regulators look for; Remediation, which shows how to evidence change over time; and Reflection, which helps you write an account that says something specific. If your concern turns on the Code itself, the NMC Ethics course covers it in depth.
What a course can and cannot do
A course can build understanding and leave you with dated evidence that you took the concern seriously. It cannot change the facts, guarantee that a case will close, or replace advice from your representative. Use it as one part of your response, guided by the people advising you.
Sources: the NMC’s pages on case examiners and their decisions, available outcomes and how case examiners decide. Check the NMC’s website for current guidance.
Courses that support insight and remediation
The courses mentioned in this guide, with CPD hours.
The four-part framework behind the insight regulators assess
How to show, with dated evidence, that the gap has been closed
Reflective accounts that say something specific
The Code in depth: candour, consent, confidentiality and professional standards
Frequently asked questions
What happens at the NMC case examiner stage?+
Who are the NMC case examiners?+
What is the NMC case to answer test?+
How long does an NMC warning stay on the register?+
What are NMC undertakings?+
Can the NMC avoid sending my case to a hearing?+
Can a case examiner decision be reviewed?+
Does completing a course change what case examiners decide?+
This is educational content, not legal advice. If you are facing a live NMC concern, contact your union, professional body or representative first. No course or outcome is guaranteed.




